No Light-Bending Material Can Be Perfectly Clear
A theoretical preprint sets a quantum limit on transparency, with the calculation not yet peer-reviewed or measured.
Updated on Nov. 7, 2026 in Physics

Theoretical physicists calculated that no light-bending material can be perfectly transparent, because quantum effects convert some light into sound. The preprint, posted October 8, 2026, is a theoretical result and has not been peer-reviewed; it is research-stage, not an available product.
Why it matters
The work sets a physical ceiling on how clear any light-bending material can get, a constraint that engineers designing optical devices will need to account for. It also reframes transparency as an energy-loss problem that can be estimated from first principles rather than only measured.
The model is a theoretical calculation published as an arXiv preprint, not a measured result. It estimates that a perfect superfluid would lose light only after traveling roughly the diameter of Earth, while Smalyukh's gels transmit very little light at a foot-thick layer, and the predicted loss has not yet been measured in any material.
The players
Ivan Smalyukh
Physicist at the University of Colorado Boulder whose lab developed gels that bend light almost as little as air does.
Angelo Esposito
Physicist who realized the energy-loss process used to detect dark photons in superfluid helium would also affect normal photons.
Borna Salehian
Physicist at ETH Zurich, not involved with the project, who commented on the findings.
The details
Light is lost when a photon transfers energy to an atomic nucleus, producing a quantum mechanical sound wave, which is a collective vibration of the material's atoms. Because photons interact with atomic nuclei repeatedly as they travel, each interaction can drain a little energy until the light becomes undetectable. The physicists modeled this in a superfluid, a fluid that flows without friction because quantum mechanics coordinates how its atoms move, and found the same energy-loss process that could help detect dark photons in superfluid helium would also affect ordinary light.
Timeline
The physicists posted their findings as a preprint on arXiv.org on October 8, 2026.
Scientific American published the article on November 7, 2026.
The Tech Race
The result sits within the research program on superfluids and dark-photon detection, where the same energy-loss process is being used as a sensing tool. It offers a theoretical limit against which the optical gels developed at the University of Colorado Boulder can be compared.
The result is a theoretical estimate and does not change any product available today. Engineers designing optical devices may use the limit to judge how close a real material can come to perfect transparency.
The takeaway
Watch for peer review of the preprint and for any measurement of the predicted light loss in a real superfluid or gel. Those results would confirm or reject the idea that the energy-loss model applies beyond superfluids.
Further reading
For background on the quantum physics behind these limits, explore more in Physics.
More information
Read the physicists' preprint on transparent materials posted to arXiv.org.
Source note: This article includes information reported by Scientific American.


