Platforms Leave Up 86% Violating Scam Content
An EU appeals body's transparency report shows independent review is reversing most moderation decisions under the Digital Services Act.
Updated on Nov. 17, 2026 in Internet

Live Poll
Do you trust social media platforms to remove scam content when it is reported?
Appeals Centre Europe, an out-of-court dispute body based in Ireland, found that social media platforms left up 1,000 potential scam items that had been reported as violating their rules, and that the content did violate those rules in 86% of cases. This is an established finding from the centre's transparency report covering October 2025 to September 2026, not a new product or policy.
Why it matters
AI-generated scams are making it harder for people to tell real from fake, which raises the stakes of how platforms moderate fraud reports. The centre's figures show that independent review under the EU's Digital Services Act is now producing measurable reversals of platform moderation decisions at scale.
The centre's figures come from its own dispute records and decision counts rather than an independent audit. Across nearly 5,000 reviewed decisions, it disagreed with platforms 74% of the time, and in about 10,000 further decisions, mainly account suspensions, it received no content from the platform and ruled procedurally for the user.
The players
Appeals Centre Europe
An Ireland-based out-of-court dispute body reviewing platform moderation decisions under the EU's Digital Services Act.
Meta (Facebook and Instagram)
The operator of Facebook and Instagram, whose moderation decisions were overturned in 67% and 75% of reviewed cases respectively.
ByteDance (TikTok)
The Chinese-owned operator of the short-video platform TikTok, whose decisions were overturned in 77% of reviewed cases.
Google (YouTube)
The operator of YouTube and Google's search and cloud services, whose decisions were overturned in 93% of YouTube cases and which supplied two pieces of content in response to more than 850 requests.
The details
Users who dispute a platform's moderation decision submit the case to Appeals Centre Europe, which checks whether the dispute is eligible and then contacts the platform for the relevant content. Where a platform does not supply the content, the centre decides on procedural grounds in the user's favour rather than on the substance of the rules. The centre's review is an out-of-court process established under the EU's Digital Services Act, which gives users a route to challenge platform decisions outside the courts.
Timeline
April to September 2026: fraud and scams were the top category of eligible disputes across the EU.
October 2025 to September 2026: the transparency report covers this period, including 43,000 disputes received.
September 2026: platform content-sharing decisions rose to nearly 100, up from around 10 in May 2026.
The Tech Race
Appeals Centre Europe's figures put a number on how often independent reviewers disagree with platform moderation under the Digital Services Act. The contest is now over whether platforms or external review bodies set the practical standard for fraud and account-suspension decisions.
Users in the EU who believe a platform wrongly removed content or suspended an account can submit a dispute to Appeals Centre Europe, and the centre's figures suggest a meaningful share of such disputes succeed. Users who report scam content should be aware that platforms do not always act on reports, as the centre found in 1,000 cases.
The takeaway
The centre's next transparency report will show whether the high overturn rates persist as scam disputes grow. Watch for Google's response to the more than 850 content requests it received, since only two pieces were supplied.
Further reading
For more on how online platforms handle fraud and content moderation, see the Internet section.
More information
Submit a dispute or read more at the Appeals Centre Europe dispute submission site.
Live Poll
Do you trust social media platforms to remove scam content when it is reported?





