We Are the Frontier

Website Tracking Software Lawsuits Move Forward

A federal court allows privacy claims to proceed regarding the unauthorized disclosure of health data to third parties.

Updated on Oct. 27, 2026 in Tech

Isometric editorial illustration of stacked server-rack panels and interconnected filaments, symbolizing the structural complexity of web-based data tracking and legal accountability.
A federal court in Michigan has ruled that a class action lawsuit against companies for unauthorized health data tracking may move forward. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

Live Poll

Do you trust websites to protect your personal health information from being shared with third parties?

A federal court has allowed a class action lawsuit to proceed against companies accused of embedding tracking software to share sensitive health and personal information with third parties. While the court dismissed a breach of fiduciary duty claim, it ruled that plaintiffs sufficiently alleged violations of the Electronic Communications Privacy Act.

Why it matters

The ruling establishes a precedent for how web-based tracking software that transmits health data to third parties without consent may trigger Electronic Communications Privacy Act liability. This development highlights the legal risk for entities using tracking tools to monetize user data.

The court's decision hinged on the application of the crime-tort exception under the Electronic Communications Privacy Act to evaluate data transmission. Plaintiffs' claims that defendants received monetary compensation for sharing personally identifiable and health information survived the initial legal challenge.

The players

Federal Court

The judicial body overseeing the litigation and ruling on the motion to dismiss in Michigan.

The details

The lawsuit centers on tracking software embedded in websites designed to harvest and disclose personally identifiable information (PII) and protected health information (PHI) to third-party entities. The court determined that the plaintiffs plausibly alleged intentional, non-consensual transmission of sensitive data to external parties. Conversely, the breach of fiduciary duty claim was dismissed due to the plaintiffs' failure to specify a cognizable injury resulting from the alleged data exposure.

Timeline

  1. October 26, 2026: Federal court issued the ruling on the defendants' motion to dismiss.

The Tech Race

This ruling aligns with broader efforts to regulate how companies leverage tracking technologies to monetize user activity. It marks a significant shift in legal oversight concerning the intersection of web analytics and protected health information.

The ongoing litigation serves as a signal for companies to audit their use of third-party tracking software that touches on sensitive health or personal data. Consumers whose health information was transmitted via these tools may see further legal developments regarding potential damages as the case proceeds.

The takeaway

This case creates a new compliance burden for organizations using tracking pixels that expose PHI or PII to third parties. Watch for further rulings on whether the plaintiffs can demonstrate specific, measurable damages as the litigation moves forward.

Further reading

Learn more about the ongoing legal landscape concerning Cybersecurity standards and data protection requirements.

Source note: This article includes information reported by Michigan Lawyers Weekly.

Live Poll

Do you trust websites to protect your personal health information from being shared with third parties?