We Are the Frontier

Low-Scoring Incumbents Lose Seats in New York

Environmental Advocates NY's scorecard tracked the defeated lawmakers, who averaged 49.7 out of 100 against a Legislature-wide mean of 64.1.

Updated on Nov. 7, 2026 in Environmental

Low-Scoring Incumbents Lose Seats in New York

Live Poll

Should voters in your area consider a legislator's environmental record when deciding who to elect?

Thirteen incumbent New York state legislators lost their seats in the November 2026 election. Environmental Advocates NY's 2026 Scorecard, released in August, had rated the defeated incumbents at an average of 49.7 out of 100. This is a reported election outcome, not a policy change.

Why it matters

Environmental Advocates NY executive director Vanessa Fajans-Turner tied the results to voters' cost concerns, and the scorecard suggests environmental voting records may now carry electoral weight in New York. Twelve of the 13 defeated incumbents were routinely failing at addressing environmental legislation, according to the group's ratings.

The scorecard is an advocacy group's composite rating of lawmakers' environmental voting, sponsorship, and public-statement records, with defeated incumbents averaging 49.7 against a Legislature-wide mean of 64.1. The extraction does not show whether the scorecard influenced voters or how the election outcomes were determined.

The players

Environmental Advocates NY

A New York environmental advocacy group whose annual legislative scorecard rates lawmakers on votes, sponsorships, and public statements.

Vanessa Fajans-Turner

Executive director of Environmental Advocates NY, who linked the election results to voters' cost concerns.

Kathy Hochul

Governor of New York, who signed a July 2026 executive order creating a statewide data center moratorium and whose data center regulation Environmental Advocates NY is monitoring.

Lisa Kaul

Candidate who defeated incumbent Sen. Robert Rolison, R-Mid-Hudson, running with climate as a top issue.

Robert Rolison

Republican state senator from the Mid-Hudson region who lost his seat to Lisa Kaul.

The details

Environmental Advocates NY built its ratings from each legislator's votes, bill sponsorships, and public statements during the last legislative session. The scores were then averaged by chamber, and the defeated incumbents were compared against those baselines. The group's methodology is a scoring system, so a lawmaker's rating reflects a weighted record of environmental actions rather than a single vote.

Timeline

  1. - July 2026: Hochul signed an executive order creating a statewide data center moratorium.

  2. - August 2026: Environmental Advocates NY released the 2026 Scorecard.

  3. - November 3, 2026: Thirteen incumbent legislators lost their seats in the election.

The Tech Race

The July 2026 data center moratorium sets a 50-megawatt threshold for state regulation, placing New York's approach to large computing facilities within the wider policy contest over AI infrastructure. The scorecard's inclusion of votes on hyperscale AI data centers ties legislative environmental records to that contest.

New York residents may see changes to environmental policy as the incoming legislature takes shape, but no specific timeline for legislative action is announced. Hochul's next steps on data center regulation remain pending, and the extraction gives no dates for them.

The takeaway

Environmental voting records are now measurable in New York election outcomes, and the next thing to watch is Gov. Kathy Hochul's response to the data center issue Environmental Advocates NY is tracking. The scorecard offers a benchmark for tracking whether that trend holds in future cycles.

Further reading

For more on the policy backdrop, see Environmental coverage across New York.

Source note: This article includes information reported by WAMC/Northeast Public Radio.

Live Poll

Should voters in your area consider a legislator's environmental record when deciding who to elect?