Biometric Ban Bills Target NYC Venue Face Scans
Proposed local bills would bar face and fingerprint collection in public places, with no passage timeline reported yet.
Updated on Nov. 3, 2026 in Cybersecurity
Live Poll
Should businesses be allowed to use facial recognition on customers in public places?
New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani criticized Madison Square Garden owner James Dolan over his use of surveillance and face-scanning technology in and around his venues. The criticism, made in a Wired interview on Tuesday, comes as Council member Shahana Hanif introduces two local bills to ban biometric data collection in public places. The surveillance practices are in use now, not proposed; the bills are proposed legislation.
Why it matters
The dispute puts facial recognition at a live-venue scale in front of city policymakers, testing whether local rules can reach private operators that track visitors. New York's 2021 biometric disclosure requirement is the existing legal baseline the proposed bans would extend.
The reporting centers on facial recognition, an approach that matches a captured face against stored templates, used here at venue entrances and across venue grounds. The documented figures are two introduced bills and a 2021 disclosure rule, with no accuracy or error-rate data in the source; the one documented misidentification led to a woman being banned from Radio City despite not being a party to the litigation.
The players
Zohran Mamdani
New York City mayor who criticized Dolan's surveillance practices and framed them as part of broader national problems.
James Dolan
Owner of Madison Square Garden and Radio City, whose companies use camera and face-scanning systems and who sued Wired over its reporting.
Shahana Hanif
New York City Council member who introduced two local bills to ban biometric data collection in public places.
The details
Facial recognition systems convert a face image into a numerical template and compare it against stored templates to identify a person. Wired reported that Dolan's company keeps a database that flags some visitors, including celebrity performers, as LGBTQIA, which raises questions about how such labels are created and stored. In 2021, a woman was barred from Radio City after the system matched her to an attorney suing Dolan's company, even though she was not involved in that litigation. Hanif's bills would prohibit collecting biometric data such as faces or fingerprints in public places across the city.
Timeline
2021: A woman was banned from Radio City after facial recognition misidentified her, and New York City began requiring businesses to disclose biometric collection from visitors.
Tuesday, November 3, 2026: Mamdani criticized Dolan in a Wired interview.
The Tech Race
New York's 2021 biometric disclosure rule is the city's existing legal reference point for private visitor tracking. Hanif's bills would move from disclosure to a prohibition in public places, a step that goes further than the rule the city adopted in 2021.
If Hanif's bills pass, New Yorkers entering venues or public spaces could no longer be scanned for biometric identifiers in those settings, though the source does not give a timeline or passage status. Visitors to Dolan's venues remain subject to face scanning and the company's visitor flags until any rule changes.
The takeaway
Watch whether Hanif's two bills advance and how their definition of public places treats private venues like Madison Square Garden and Radio City. Also track whether Madison Square Garden responds to the Wired reporting, which it has not yet done publicly.
Further reading
For the wider policy context, see Cybersecurity coverage of how data collection rules are being tested in New York City.
Live Poll
Should businesses be allowed to use facial recognition on customers in public places?
