We Are the Frontier

AI Assists Surgeons, Not Replaces Them Yet

A Sanford Health surgeon says robotics needs major advances before AI could operate, as public trust in AI-driven care lags.

Updated on Nov. 1, 2026 in Artificial Intelligence

Brushed steel robotic surgical arm extended over an empty draped operating table in a sterile, cool-lit operating room.
Sanford Health surgeon Joshua Knudson says robotics would need major advances before AI could operate, as public trust in AI-driven care lags. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

Live Poll

Would you feel comfortable with AI assisting your doctor during your own surgery?

Sanford Health surgeon Joshua Knudson weighed in on the role of artificial intelligence in surgery, saying robotics would need major advancements before AI could perform operations. The discussion is analytical and centers on public attitudes rather than a shipped surgical AI product.

Why it matters

Public comfort is a constraint on how fast AI moves into clinical care, and a nationwide Pew Research Center study found six in ten Americans would feel uncomfortable with doctors relying on AI for personal care. For Bismarck residents and the wider North Dakota health system, the question is less whether AI can assist surgeons than how quickly trust and capability can catch up.

The figures come from a nationwide Pew Research Center public opinion study, which reports that six in ten Americans are uncomfortable with doctors relying on AI for personal care while about 40% believe AI could reduce medical mistakes. The source does not report any measured performance benchmark for an AI surgical system, and the reasons behind the split in opinion remain unexplained.

The players

Sanford Health

A North Dakota-based health system whose surgeon offered the perspective on AI in operating rooms.

Joshua Knudson

A Sanford Health surgeon who said robotics must advance substantially before AI could perform surgery.

Pew Research Center

A nonpartisan U.S. research organization that conducts national public opinion studies on technology and society.

The details

Surgeons currently use robotic systems that extend their hands and vision, but the AI discussed here would have to move from assisting a human operator to making or executing decisions inside the body. Doctors interviewed describe the intended role of AI in the operating room as support for human surgeons rather than replacement. Knudson argued that robotics would need major advancements first, while noting that AI systems able to drive cars could plausibly learn to operate.

Timeline

  1. Pew Research Center's nationwide study on public attitudes toward AI in medical care has no specific release date given in this report.

The Tech Race

The debate tracks a broader race to bring AI from diagnostic and assistive roles into direct clinical action, a shift that depends on both robotics maturity and public acceptance. Pew's finding that six in ten Americans are uncomfortable with AI handling personal care suggests trust is likely to pace adoption as much as engineering does.

Patients are unlikely to encounter AI performing surgery in the near term, since surgeon Joshua Knudson said robotics would need major advancements first. Patients in Bismarck and across North Dakota may instead see AI continue to support clinicians, while the Pew findings suggest many patients will expect a physician to remain in control.

The takeaway

Watch whether public comfort with AI in medical care shifts as clinicians adopt more assistive tools, since the Pew study's six-in-ten discomfort figure is a baseline for measuring that change. Surgeon Joshua Knudson's argument that robotics must advance first offers a concrete test: a future surgical robotics milestone would show whether AI is moving closer to the operating table.

Further reading

For broader context, explore the Artificial Intelligence coverage that tracks where these tools are heading.

Source note: This article includes information reported by Kfyrtv.

Live Poll

Would you feel comfortable with AI assisting your doctor during your own surgery?